New Ranking: Best of the best Pizza in Toronto, ON — 329 Entries Sorted Down to 143

We just published a new consensus ranking: Best of the best Pizza in Toronto, ON. We asked 17 AI models to independently rank the best pizza placess, then sorted through 329 raw entries to build one definitive consensus list.

The Consensus Winner

Pizzeria Libretto takes the #1 spot with a 95% AI Agreement score. 17 out of 17 AI models included it in their rankings — a unanimous pick.

Close behind is North of Brooklyn Pizzeria with 84% AI agreement, also appearing on the vast majority of AI lists.

How the AIs Agreed (and Disagreed)

The chart above shows how strongly the AI models agree on each of the top 5 picks. Higher percentages mean more AIs ranked it similarly. A score above 80% signals very strong consensus — the AIs really do agree this pizza places is one of the best.

The Sorting Funnel: From 329 to 143

Here is where the slop gets sorted. We started with 329 raw entries from 17 AI models. After intelligent deduplication (merging entries like "La Nova" and "La Nova Pizzeria"), we ended up with 143 unique pizza placess. Of those, 45 were recommended by multiple AIs — those are the signal. The remaining 98 were single-AI picks that get penalized in our scoring.

Which AIs Got It Right?

Not all AI models perform equally. The chart shows how each model scored on accuracy for this specific ranking — measuring how well their picks aligned with the final consensus. Gemini 3.1 Pro led the pack at 64%.

Key Stats

See the full ranking: Best of the best Pizza in Toronto, ON. Learn more about how our scoring works.