Jay's Artisan Pizzeria
🔀 Merged from 1 variants
Jay's Artisan Pizza

Name: Jay's Artisan Pizzeria
Rating: 2.9 (5 reviews)

📊 49% AI Agreement🏆 Rank #8🤖 5 of 14 AIs

👑×2#5×1#8×1#20×1

🔗 www.jaysbuffalo.com🏆 2.9 SlopSort Rating⭐ 4.6 Google Rating (Feb 2026)✓ Google Verified

📍 View Map

📍 2872 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217, United States

🤖 The AI Verdict

Jay's Artisan Pizzeria was ranked by 5 out of 14 AI models consulted. It achieved a consensus rank of #8 with a 49% AI agreement score. The average position given by the AIs was #7.0.

AI Agreement Meter

49%

Low Agreement

5 of 14 AI models included this

0% 50% 100%

Where Each AI Ranked This

Gemini 2.5 Pro

Claude Opus 4.6

Grok

DeepSeek

DeepSeek R1

#20

Range: #1 – #20 Wide spread — AIs disagree significantly

AI Rankings Breakdown

View Full AI Breakdown (5 models)

Points = base position score × AI weight. Higher-weighted AIs contribute more points per position.

AI Model	Rank Given	Weighted Points
Gemini 2.5 Pro(1.55x)	#1	29 pts
Claude Opus 4.6(1.63x)	#1	32 pts
Grok(1.63x)	#5	26 pts
DeepSeek(1.50x)	#8	19 pts
DeepSeek R1(1.52x)	#20	2 pts

Badges Earned

🔥

Most Debated

AIs disagreed the most about where to rank this — some loved it, others didn't.

🛩️

Under the Radar

Not many AIs mentioned this one, but it ranked significantly higher than expected.

Neighborhood: 5 AIs reported

Gemini 2.5 Pro: "Kenmore"

DeepSeek R1: "Elmwood Village"

Claude Opus 4.6: "Elmwood Village"

DeepSeek: "Black Rock"

Grok: "Kenmore (bordering Buffalo)"

reason: 5 AIs reported

Gemini 2.5 Pro: "Ranked #6 in the entire USA for 2024, this spot is nationally recognized for its amazing Neapolitan and Detroit-style pizzas. [stepoutbuffalo.com]"

DeepSeek R1: "Gourmet thin-crust with seasonal local ingredients and creative combos."

Claude Opus 4.6: "Wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies with locally sourced ingredients, consistently ranked as Buffalo's best pizza by local critics and national publications"

DeepSeek: "Artisanal, wood-fired pizzas made with high-quality ingredients."

Grok: "Wood-fired pizzas with creative toppings and high-quality dough"

How Close Was It?

Gap to #7 above

-20.243150000000014 points (10%)

Notable gap

Picasso's Pizza: 208.72118 pts

Lead over #9 below

+8.725209999999976 points

Slim lead

Lovejoy Pizza: 179.75282 pts

Other Products in This Ranking