👍 Rate this Consensus 🏆 Create your own Top 5 Pizza Places list 🗳️ Request a Ranking

Maker Pizza
🔀 Merged from 1 variants
Pizza Pizza (Little Italy)

📊 78% AI Agreement🏆 Rank #5🤖 12 of 17 AIs
🥈×1🥉×3#4×3#5×2#6×3
🔗 www.makerpizza.com🏆 3.8 SlopSort Rating⭐ 4.4 Google Rating (2026-03-13)✓ Google Verified
📍 View 6 Maps
📍 59 Cameron St, Toronto, ON M5T 0E4, Canada
📍 1674 Bayview Ave, Toronto, ON M4S 0C9, Canada
📍 181B Carlaw Ave, Toronto, ON M4M 1K1, Canada
📍 8020 Bathurst St Building B, Unit 4B, Thornhill, ON L4J 0B8, Canada
📍 465 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M5V 2A9, Canada
📍 96 Tecumseth St., Toronto, ON M6J 2H1, Canada

🤖 The AI Verdict

Maker Pizza was ranked by 12 out of 17 AI models consulted. It achieved a consensus rank of #5 with a 78% AI agreement score. The average position given by the AIs was #4.3.

AI Agreement Meter
78%
High Agreement
12 of 17 AI models included this
0% 50% 100%
Where Each AI Ranked This
Grok
#2
Gemini 2.5 Pro
#3
GLM 5
#3
Claude Opus 4.6
#3
Gemini 3 Pro
#4
Mini Max M2.1
#4
DeepSeek
#4
Claude Sonnet 4.5
#5
GPT - 5.2
#5
Gemini 2.5 Flash
#6
Mistral Large
#6
DeepSeek R1
#6
Range: #2 – #6 Wide spread — AIs disagree significantly
AI Rankings Breakdown
View Full AI Breakdown (12 models)

Points = base position score × AI weight. Higher-weighted AIs contribute more points per position.

AI ModelRank GivenWeighted Points
Grok(1.63x) #2 31 pts
Gemini 2.5 Pro(1.55x) #3 26 pts
GLM 5(1.57x) #3 26 pts
Claude Opus 4.6(1.63x) #3 28 pts
Gemini 3 Pro(1.59x) #4 11 pts
Mini Max M2.1(1.53x) #4 26 pts
DeepSeek(1.50x) #4 25 pts
Claude Sonnet 4.5(1.55x) #5 24 pts
GPT - 5.2(1.56x) #5 25 pts
Gemini 2.5 Flash(1.62x) #6 24 pts
Mistral Large(1.54x) #6 24 pts
DeepSeek R1(1.52x) #6 21 pts
Badges Earned
🎯
Tight Consensus
The AIs that ranked this product placed it in very similar positions — they agree on exactly where it belongs.
reason: 12 AIs reported
Claude Opus 4.6: "Known for inventive signature pies, house-made dough, and a fun atmosphere with an open kitchen concept that draws loyal crowds"
Gemini 2.5 Pro: "Co-founded by chef Matty Matheson, this spot is known for revolutionizing delivery with creative toppings and a popular sesame or everything-bagel crust option [streetsoftoronto.com](https://streetsoftoronto.com/best_of_toronto/essential-pizzas-in-toronto-you-need-to-try-at-least-once/)."
GLM 5: "Famous for its "fast craft" approach, offering creative topping combinations on a perfectly crispy yet chewy crust in a casual, energetic setting."
DeepSeek R1: "Creative topping combinations and artisanal approach in a stylish setting."
Claude Sonnet 4.5: "Sourdough Neapolitan pizzas with inventive seasonal toppings, house-made ingredients, and a commitment to local sourcing in a trendy space."
Mini Max M2.1: "Community-favorite with consistently excellent quality wood-fired pizzas and house-made toppings"
Gemini 2.5 Flash: "Innovative and gourmet pizzas with unique flavour profiles and high-quality dough."
Gemini 3 Pro: "Developed with celebrity chef Matty Matheson, offering high-quality delivery pies with a unique three-day aged dough and generous toppings."
GPT - 5.2: "Modern Toronto classic for creative topping combos, great crust texture, and consistently strong bakes across styles"
DeepSeek: "Celebrity-backed, creative toppings, and a perfectly chewy, flavorful crust with a dedicated following."
Mistral Large: "Known for its sourdough pizzas with unique, globally inspired toppings and a relaxed vibe."
Grok: "Creative toppings and high-quality dough, often ranked as Toronto's best slice"
How Close Was It?
Gap to #4 above
-112.34559999999993 points (21%)
Significant gap
Pizzeria Badiali: 544.0998 pts
Lead over #6 below
+144.70464000000004 points
Dominant lead
Queen Margherita Pizza: 287.04956 pts
Other Products in This Ranking
#4 – Previous
Pizzeria Badiali
Next – #6
Queen Margherita Pizza
← Back to Full Ranking