👍 Rate this Consensus 🏆 Create your own Top 5 Pizza Places list 🗳️ Request a Ranking
#18

JJ's Casa Di Pizza
🔀 Merged from 1 variants
Casa Di Pizza

📊 39% AI Agreement🏆 Rank #18🤖 4 of 14 AIs
#9×1#14×1#17×1#19×1

🤖 The AI Verdict

JJ's Casa Di Pizza was ranked by 4 out of 14 AI models consulted. It achieved a consensus rank of #18 with a 39% AI agreement score. The average position given by the AIs was #14.8.

Sponsored The Right Board Makes All the Difference Shop Chess Boards on Amazon →
AI Agreement Meter
39%
Very Low Agreement
4 of 14 AI models included this
0% 50% 100%
Where Each AI Ranked This
Gemini 2.5 Pro
#9
Claude Opus 4.6
#14
Claude Sonnet 4.5
#17
Gemini 2.5 Flash
#19
Range: #9 – #19 Wide spread — AIs disagree significantly
AI Rankings Breakdown
View Full AI Breakdown (4 models)

Points = base position score × AI weight. Higher-weighted AIs contribute more points per position.

AI ModelRank GivenWeighted Points
Gemini 2.5 Pro(1.38x) #9 17 pts
Claude Opus 4.6(1.62x) #14 11 pts
Claude Sonnet 4.5(1.52x) #17 6 pts
Gemini 2.5 Flash(1.58x) #19 3 pts
Badges Earned
🛩️
Under the Radar
Not many AIs mentioned this one, but it ranked significantly higher than expected.
Neighborhood: 4 AIs reported
Gemini 2.5 Pro: "North Buffalo"
Claude Opus 4.6: "Multiple Buffalo locations"
Claude Sonnet 4.5: "West Side"
Gemini 2.5 Flash: "Downtown"
reason: 4 AIs reported
Gemini 2.5 Pro: "A long-standing family restaurant notable for serving classic Buffalo-style pizza while also being one of the few places in the area offering deep-dish pizza. [wearebuffalo.net]"
Claude Opus 4.6: "Regional chain beloved for its thick, bready crust and generous cheese coverage, a comfort food staple across the Buffalo area"
Claude Sonnet 4.5: "West side gem with excellent thin crust and generous toppings at great value"
Gemini 2.5 Flash: "A historic Buffalo establishment known for its classic pizza and vibrant atmosphere."
Sponsored HotPot Shop Amazons selection of Hot Pot's →
How Close Was It?
Gap to #17 above
-3.281729999999996 points (5%)
Razor thin
Macy's Place Pizzeria: 71.53934 pts
Lead over #19 below
+6.965609999999998 points
Slim lead
Carbone's Pizza & Subs: 61.292 pts
Other Products in This Ranking
#17 – Previous
Macy's Place Pizzeria
Next – #19
Carbone's Pizza & Subs
← Back to Full Ranking