Home › Categories › Pizza› Best of the best Pizza in Toronto, ON › Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria
👍 Rate this Consensus 🏆 Create your own Top 5 Pizza Places list 🗳️ Request a Ranking
#13

Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria
🔀 Merged from 3 variants
The Fourth Man in the Fire PizzeriaFourth Man in the FireThe Fourth Man in the Fire

📊 46% AI Agreement🏆 Rank #13🤖 7 of 17 AIs
#6×1#9×2#10×2#13×1#16×1
🔗 www.thefourthmaninthefirepizzeria.com⭐ 4.5 Google Rating (2026-03-13)✓ Google Verified
📍 View Map
📍 832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, Canada

🤖 The AI Verdict

Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria was ranked by 7 out of 17 AI models consulted. It achieved a consensus rank of #13 with a 46% AI agreement score. The average position given by the AIs was #10.4.

Sponsored The Right Board Makes All the Difference Shop Chess Boards on Amazon →
AI Agreement Meter
46%
Low Agreement
7 of 17 AI models included this
0% 50% 100%
Where Each AI Ranked This
Gemini 3.1 Pro
#6
Gemini 2.5 Pro
#9
Perplexity
#9
DeepSeek
#10
Gemini 2.5 Flash
#10
GPT - 5.2
#13
DeepSeek R1
#16
Range: #6 – #16 Wide spread — AIs disagree significantly
AI Rankings Breakdown
View Full AI Breakdown (7 models)

Points = base position score × AI weight. Higher-weighted AIs contribute more points per position.

AI ModelRank GivenWeighted Points
Gemini 3.1 Pro(1.65x) #6 8 pts
Gemini 2.5 Pro(1.38x) #9 16 pts
Perplexity(1.12x) #9 13 pts
DeepSeek(1.49x) #10 15 pts
Gemini 2.5 Flash(1.58x) #10 15 pts
GPT - 5.2(1.42x) #13 11 pts
DeepSeek R1(1.41x) #16 7 pts
Badges Earned
🎯
Tight Consensus
The AIs that ranked this product placed it in very similar positions — they agree on exactly where it belongs.
reason: 7 AIs reported
Gemini 2.5 Pro: "Serves classic, well-executed American-style pizzas with a perfectly chewy crust and quality toppings in a relaxed, no-frills setting."
Perplexity: "NYC-inspired with magnificent fennel-flecked sausage and onion pizza, Italian-American charm[2]"
Gemini 2.5 Flash: "Delicious wood-fired pizzas with a great selection of classic and unique toppings."
GPT - 5.2: "Excellent naturally leavened-style crust and thoughtfully composed pies with standout char and texture"
DeepSeek: "Outstanding sourdough crust, creative seasonal toppings, and a commitment to fire-cooked perfection."
Gemini 3.1 Pro: "Known for American-style, slightly thicker crust pizzas that are sturdy, nostalgic, and loaded with classic toppings."
DeepSeek R1: "Sourdough crust pizzas with seasonal toppings and natural wine pairings."
Sponsored HotPot Shop Amazons selection of Hot Pot's →
How Close Was It?
Gap to #12 above
-0.3196800000000053 points
Razor thin
General Assembly Pizza: 142.83868 pts
Lead over #14 below
+5.870490000000018 points
Slim lead
Pizzeria Defina: 136.64851 pts
Other Products in This Ranking
#1
Pizzeria Libretto
95% AI agreement
#2
North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
84% AI agreement
#3
Pizzeria Badiali
76% AI agreement
#4
Descendant Detroit Style Pizza
87% AI agreement
#5
Maker Pizza
78% AI agreement
#6
Queen Margherita Pizza
59% AI agreement
#7
Superpoint
56% AI agreement
#8
Pizzeria Via Mercanti
55% AI agreement
←
#12 – Previous
General Assembly Pizza
Next – #14
Pizzeria Defina
→
← Back to Full Ranking